3 – 2
“Julian Hall opened the scoring early to give New York Red Bulls the lead, striking inside the first ten minutes to set the tone for an end-to-end encounter.”
Pivotal“Max Arfsten levelled for Columbus Crew, restoring parity and rewarding the visitors' growing dominance of possession in the opening quarter.”
“Hall struck again just before the break to restore New York's advantage, completing a devastating one-two punch before half-time that left Columbus chasing the game heading into the interval.”
Pivotal“Diego Rossi converted from the penalty spot to make it 2-2, drawing Columbus level and resetting the contest just as New York had looked to be managing the game towards a comfortable win after their double substitution response.”
Pivotal“Hall completed his hat-trick with a 78th-minute winner to restore New York's lead for the third time, this time with just over ten minutes remaining — a blow from which Columbus could not recover.”
PivotalOutstanding performance

New York Red Bulls overcame a familiar challenge from Columbus Crew in a match that defied their statistical disadvantage on the night. Despite surrendering 69 percent of possession and being outpassed more than two-to-one, the Red Bulls were ruthless when it mattered — creating four big chances to Columbus's two and converting three of them through Julian Hall alone. Hall was the story of the evening: his early opener set the tone, his second just before the hour of the first half re-established the lead after Max Arfsten had levelled, and his 78th-minute winner ultimately proved the difference after Diego Rossi had drawn Columbus level from the penalty spot on 64 minutes. Columbus, for all their composure on the ball, could not find a way past a Red Bulls side that tackled relentlessly — 20 tackles to Columbus's 15 — and made the most of their limited but incisive attacking moments. For New York, the three points will ease pressure in a tight MLS standings picture and builds on what the form metrics suggested was a side gathering momentum. For Columbus, the manner of the defeat — dominating possession yet losing to a hat-trick from a single forward — will sting, and the five yellow cards picked up collectively underline how the tension of the occasion got to both sides.
How entertaining was this match?